How to get people to use Mastodon?
-
The server selection problem goes away if people stop treating their hosting website as an after thought or dumb terminal. People really have to stop promoting web server software as if it's a platform, and start finding reasons to recommend actual websites to people.
Ain't nobody ever recommended phpBB to anyone who wasn't looking to host a forum.
-
Sure, but phpBB boards are separate entities, not parts of a whole... So that's not really a 1 to 1 comparison, IMO.
That being said, you're right. If people started sharing instances directly instead of just saying "Mastodon," this issue would be attenuated, at the very least.
The issue is that people want the social part of social media. If you share mastodon.social, people will think "Mastodon," but if you share indieweb.social people will be confused, and possible disinterested because they don't necessarily expect to be connected to the other "Mastodons." At the end of the day, you'll always have to say it's a "Mastodon Server," and as soon as that gets brought up, I'm afraid it might push people away before they even get a foot in.
Then again, that's kind of how Discord gets shared around, so maybe that's OK, IDK.
-
The geolocalized choosing is a great idea! Sometimes you join based on communities as well, in that case a “join custom server” button could be added!
-
a “join custom server” button could be added!
100%!
-
It’s not about it being for adults or for children. Mastodon is indeed a weird name, and people who have never heard of this platform with lots of things on their mind are more likely to dismiss it if it doesn’t immediately capture their attention / they don’t immediately know what it means.
While this naming “issue” is definitely on the bottom of priorities, I do find it worth mentioning, if only just for the sake of conversation. Plus, it’s kind of interesting to think about how something that, at first, doesn’t seem that important might influence the success of a product.
-
Mastodon servers are separate entities, too. The fact that they communicate with each other doesn't change that, and the persistent desire that folks here have to imagine otherwise is a hurdle to adoption.
The mental model is of a central space that instances grant or bar access to, but that's simply not how the technology actually works. Too much effort has gone into trying to make ActivityPub-enabled websites look like something they're not (centralized social media), while totally ignoring what they are: small forums and microblogs that have optional access to other forums and microblogs.
Mastodon is web server software. "Mastodon" doesn't exist. It's an illusion. And the fact that everyone keeps trying to sell this illusion is exactly why there are all of these broken expectations and hurdles.
-
When I told my best friend about mastodon, it misimprinted on her brain in a flash as "walrus chat" and now she can't for the life of her remember its actual name.
-
Oh man. I had forgotten Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup. I think I last played that in high school.
-
My gut reaction was to reject what you said, but the more I think about it... You might have a point.
I don't know. I don't want to say too much and regret it, but you did give me plenty to think about. Thank you for your contribution to the discussion.
-
Ah ha, a fellow crawler! The game's still going and getting updated!
