Weird Crosspost, but...
-
How could so many operators coordinate and then disappear? Seems that there were no Ukrainians nearby. FPV operating via Internet would be impossible due to lags and unstable signal.
ArduPilot sounds like it could make high latency piloting possible:
ArduPilot can handle tasks like stabilizing a drone in the air while the pilot focuses on moving to their next objective. Pilots can switch them into loitering mode, for example, if they need to step away or perform another task, and it has failsafe modes that keep a drone aloft if signal is lost.
-
It's sad to see something made out of love for humanity used for war.
wrote on last edited by [email protected]Lmao, how can you be sure it's made out of love for humanity? Open source is not always about love or altruism. Most of the times it's just some dude making something for themselves and just have more reason putting it out in the open than selling it. Sometimes it's just boredom and curiosity, sometimes it's about hubris and vanity.
-
It's sad to see something made out of love for humanity used for war.
You can say that to just about anything. Every weapon system uses stuff that was not developed for this use case. Because so many things are involved there.
-
@jsomae it's used to prevent civilian deaths by destroying the weapon that did that. Sounds like love to me. These planes killed children.
That's just how war is though. War is always justified by the enemy. I'm not saying it's sad that they choose to defend themselves -- it's sad that they're in a situation where they must.
-
How could so many operators coordinate and then disappear? Seems that there were no Ukrainians nearby. FPV operating via Internet would be impossible due to lags and unstable signal.
I've read they attach fiber cables to drones to avoid interference
-
cross-posted from: https://dubvee.org/post/3516835
Ukraine used ArduPilot to help it wipe out Russian targets. It wasn’t the first time and it won’t be the last.
Open source software used by hobbyist drones powered an attack that wiped out a third of Russia’s strategic long range bombers on Sunday afternoon, in one of the most daring and technically coordinated attacks in the war.
In broad daylight on Sunday, explosions rocked air bases in Belaya, Olenya, and Ivanovo in Russia, which are hundreds of miles from Ukraine. The Security Services of Ukraine’s (SBU) Operation Spider Web was a coordinated assault on Russian targets it claimed was more than a year in the making, which was carried out using a nearly 20-year-old piece of open source drone autopilot software called ArduPilot.
ArduPilot’s original creators were in awe of the attack. “That's ArduPilot, launched from my basement 18 years ago. Crazy,” Chris Anderson said in a comment on LinkedIn below footage of the attack.
wrote on last edited by [email protected]10 years ago I got into RC planes for a summer, and me and the guy were talking about how ridiculous it is that the milirary is spending so much money on simple drones, when they could just strap some explosives on a cheap hobbyist RC plane/drone for a fraction of the price, and just create swarms of them.
The technology had been widely available for some time already back then. Turns out, it was just lacking a war to do so.
(Just to be clear, we were all anti-war in general, this was just idle speculatiok back then. But if our country was attacked at that time, I'm sure some of us would have ended in a newly created drone force like what happened in the Ukraine.)
-
I've read they attach fiber cables to drones to avoid interference
This attack hit airbases all over Russia. Smuggling operators into Siberia to fly the drones seems unreasonable.
-
incredible self-own from ArduPilot co-creator Jason Short:
Not in a million years would I have predicted this outcome. I just wanted to make flying robots.
(of course, in reality, many people were discussing weaponization even on the day diydrones was announced...)
wrote on last edited by [email protected]I mean, that's a pretty believable claim. Most open source developers don't even think their project will be noticed by a lot of people, let alone be used for military purposes. At worst you can accuse him of being ignorant of the realities of how his software will be used but I honestly don't think he was outright lying and secretly wanted his software to be used in weapons or something.
-
It's sad to see something made out of love for humanity used for war.
Like humans?
-
This attack hit airbases all over Russia. Smuggling operators into Siberia to fly the drones seems unreasonable.
Yeah you're definitely right
-
10 years ago I got into RC planes for a summer, and me and the guy were talking about how ridiculous it is that the milirary is spending so much money on simple drones, when they could just strap some explosives on a cheap hobbyist RC plane/drone for a fraction of the price, and just create swarms of them.
The technology had been widely available for some time already back then. Turns out, it was just lacking a war to do so.
(Just to be clear, we were all anti-war in general, this was just idle speculatiok back then. But if our country was attacked at that time, I'm sure some of us would have ended in a newly created drone force like what happened in the Ukraine.)
Unfortunately, a rather substantial portion of warfare is the economics behind it. Often, spending eye-watering amounts of money on proprietary, overpriced hardware is the point. It's corporate welfare.
-
Unfortunately, a rather substantial portion of warfare is the economics behind it. Often, spending eye-watering amounts of money on proprietary, overpriced hardware is the point. It's corporate welfare.
wrote on last edited by [email protected]Yeah, especially in peace time. When war heats up and resources get scarce, you use the cheapest thing that does the job. But in peace time you feed your military contractors to keep them happy and to keep them researching and developing so you don't lose out on modern technology development.
(For clarification, with "war time" I mean "being in a war that actually threatens the country". The US hasn't been in a war like that for a very long time. They've essentially being in "peace time" while having military training and testing facilities in the middle east.)
-
It's sad to see something made out of love for humanity used for war.
If you think about it, this was perhaps the most humane way to conduct war. No humans were harmed in this attack, and the ability to harm humans was severely degraded. You had drones smash into unmanned airplanes. Nothing but money and hardware was lost. This is the utopian version of war if such a thing could ever exist. One country removes another country's ability to harm humans with nobody getting hurt and everyone gets to go home.
