Who tried a generic extended-release methylphenidate instead of their usual?
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Can it really be so much different? Both claim to have a 50 % instant-release part.
Medikinet removed has a similar curve as Ritalin LA with a stronger peak between hour 3 and 6. The Zentiva isn't even documented that well. German article with interesting comparison graphs: https://www.ppt-online.de/heftarchiv/2022/04/individuelle-adhs-therapie-mit-methylphenidat-*removed*praeparaten.html
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Can it really be so much different? Both claim to have a 50 % instant-release part.
Medikinet removed has a similar curve as Ritalin LA with a stronger peak between hour 3 and 6. The Zentiva isn't even documented that well. German article with interesting comparison graphs: https://www.ppt-online.de/heftarchiv/2022/04/individuelle-adhs-therapie-mit-methylphenidat-*removed*praeparaten.html
Generic extended release methylphenidate was what my primary care doc first tried me on. I noticed it a little and thought ok, it's still really hard to function. What do people mean that getting on medication was a game changer for them?
After about a year of this, trudging through my day still, I got in to see a psych about a month ago who switched me to Vyvanse, and holy cow. I'm functioning again! Wtf?!
I will say that my sleep has suffered some, but that's a little bit on me for not taking my meds early enough in the day.
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Can it really be so much different? Both claim to have a 50 % instant-release part.
Medikinet removed has a similar curve as Ritalin LA with a stronger peak between hour 3 and 6. The Zentiva isn't even documented that well. German article with interesting comparison graphs: https://www.ppt-online.de/heftarchiv/2022/04/individuelle-adhs-therapie-mit-methylphenidat-*removed*praeparaten.html
I am on the extended release (ER) for methylphenidate on a high dose for like 20 years and for me it lets me focus while it is working.
Sustained release (SR) does not work nearly as well for me. Standard release wears off way too fast.
People have very different rates of success or side effects so yes, it really could be that different! It sounds like this isn't the right one for your kiddo.
-
Generic extended release methylphenidate was what my primary care doc first tried me on. I noticed it a little and thought ok, it's still really hard to function. What do people mean that getting on medication was a game changer for them?
After about a year of this, trudging through my day still, I got in to see a psych about a month ago who switched me to Vyvanse, and holy cow. I'm functioning again! Wtf?!
I will say that my sleep has suffered some, but that's a little bit on me for not taking my meds early enough in the day.
wrote last edited by [email protected]It is funny because Vyvanse gave me weird side effects without any benefit (too long ago to remember) while the ER methylphenidate had a progressively more effective benefit with zero side effects for me as the dosage went up to the one I settled on. Been taking it for years and have to justify to insurance once a year that no, I don't want to try the ones that didn't work just let me stay on this.
Glad to hear you found one that works for you!
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Can it really be so much different? Both claim to have a 50 % instant-release part.
Medikinet removed has a similar curve as Ritalin LA with a stronger peak between hour 3 and 6. The Zentiva isn't even documented that well. German article with interesting comparison graphs: https://www.ppt-online.de/heftarchiv/2022/04/individuelle-adhs-therapie-mit-methylphenidat-*removed*praeparaten.html
Looks like the post is referring to a Medikinet product that could also be described as delayed release or modified release, instead of the word which was censored in the post. In case anyone else was confused like me.
-
Generic extended release methylphenidate was what my primary care doc first tried me on. I noticed it a little and thought ok, it's still really hard to function. What do people mean that getting on medication was a game changer for them?
After about a year of this, trudging through my day still, I got in to see a psych about a month ago who switched me to Vyvanse, and holy cow. I'm functioning again! Wtf?!
I will say that my sleep has suffered some, but that's a little bit on me for not taking my meds early enough in the day.
You can try something like 1mg extended release melatonin for sleep
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Can it really be so much different? Both claim to have a 50 % instant-release part.
Medikinet removed has a similar curve as Ritalin LA with a stronger peak between hour 3 and 6. The Zentiva isn't even documented that well. German article with interesting comparison graphs: https://www.ppt-online.de/heftarchiv/2022/04/individuelle-adhs-therapie-mit-methylphenidat-*removed*praeparaten.html
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Unrelated to your question, but please, I need to know what word dot ml decided to filter out lol
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Unrelated to your question, but please, I need to know what word dot ml decided to filter out lol
wrote last edited by [email protected]The "r word" (retard) as in slow release
-
The "r word" (retard) as in slow release
wrote last edited by [email protected]Of course
Edit: they'll filter it even if you're french
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Can it really be so much different? Both claim to have a 50 % instant-release part.
Medikinet removed has a similar curve as Ritalin LA with a stronger peak between hour 3 and 6. The Zentiva isn't even documented that well. German article with interesting comparison graphs: https://www.ppt-online.de/heftarchiv/2022/04/individuelle-adhs-therapie-mit-methylphenidat-*removed*praeparaten.html
Adult on time release generic methylphenidate here. I notice it usually starts working about 45 minutes after ingestion. Instant release only really means as soon as it begins to be digested and everybody's body is different.
Also remember, don't mix it with caffeine or the effects will be greatly reduced.
-
My child had to switch from Medikinet removed to the Zentiva version. Teachers said the generic is hardly working at all.
Unrelated to your question, but please, I need to know what word dot ml decided to filter out lol
Same. "XR"?
