The Astronomer and the Amateur meet on Wikipedia
-
wrote last edited by [email protected]
The Moon is made of green cheese.
or, an editor's personal recounting of a painful conversation
-
The Moon is made of green cheese.
or, an editor's personal recounting of a painful conversation
wrote last edited by [email protected]Here’s how the conversation should have ended:
Amateur: The Moon is made of green cheese.
Astronomer: No it's not, it's made (after oxygen) of silicon, aluminium, calcium, magnesium, and iron.
Amateur: Find me a citation that says it's not made of green cheese.
Astronomer: Here's a chart I just found in my files and uploaded which gives the composition.
Amateur: How do you know that's what it is? I say it's a chart of the composition of Pluto.
Astronomer: Understandable. Have a nice day.
The conversation was painful because the astronomer didn’t know when to stop talking.
-
Here’s how the conversation should have ended:
Amateur: The Moon is made of green cheese.
Astronomer: No it's not, it's made (after oxygen) of silicon, aluminium, calcium, magnesium, and iron.
Amateur: Find me a citation that says it's not made of green cheese.
Astronomer: Here's a chart I just found in my files and uploaded which gives the composition.
Amateur: How do you know that's what it is? I say it's a chart of the composition of Pluto.
Astronomer: Understandable. Have a nice day.
The conversation was painful because the astronomer didn’t know when to stop talking.
Unfortunately that's not conducive to getting the verifiable facts in an article.
As I mention, this is a retelling of a real conversation the author had:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:History_of_the_Internet/Archive_3#Pictures
