Germany’s election winner pledges ‘independence from US’
-
Question is how much they actually do what they said before, when they are in power.
Merz has been talking heavily about more support for Ukraine, when it served to drive a wedge between the previous government, as the former coalition partner FDP wanted to use Ukraine support spending to cut social spending and climate investments.
The whole reason that is possible is a "debt limit" article in the constitution, that prohibits the country from taking on new debt, even if that debt is used for investments that will pay back much more money. This article was put in place mainly by the CDU but tolerated by the SPD a few years back. The CDU also sued against using leftover money from the emergency Covid fund to finance green investment. Green investment would have reduced the need for energy imports, including direct and indirect imports from Russia, which would have helped Ukraine. Also it put much more pressure onto the public budget, which reduced the legroom for Ukraine support.
The goal of the CDU was solely to use this to blow up the previous government, which eventually succeeded. Meanwhile the CDU worked hard to establish the radical pro Putin AfD Nazis further and it is possible that they will form the next government together.
Merz has ruled out forming a government with AfD hasn't he? I think he did on TV last night. So I assume he will try to form a government with SPD.
Anyway, I really am not massively informed on German politics. But I've heard a couple of good things from Merz so far (his support for Ukraine, and his desire to make Europe more independent of the USA). I hope he will maintain his commitment to those ideas.
-
By a meagre 2% too
CDU/CSU: 29%
AfD: 21%
where do your 2% come from? -
Is it though? I think both parties align quite well on a lot of issues.
Then you don't know much about German politics.
-
Merz has ruled out forming a government with AfD hasn't he? I think he did on TV last night. So I assume he will try to form a government with SPD.
Anyway, I really am not massively informed on German politics. But I've heard a couple of good things from Merz so far (his support for Ukraine, and his desire to make Europe more independent of the USA). I hope he will maintain his commitment to those ideas.
Merz also said that he would never accept any working together with the AfD, not in public not in private. Anyone in the CDU that would do so, would be kicked out of the party immediately.
Now whjat we have seen instead on the past year is the CDU working together with the AfD often on the local and state level. on the federal level they finally worked together about three weeks back, when they first passed a resolution against Migration and then barely failed to pass a law together. Merz said, it isn't his fault if the AfD was voting together with them and if the other parties weren't willing to pass the [far right anti human rights anti constitutional rights] laws together with them.
https://www.dw.com/en/german-lawmakers-reject-contentious-immigration-law/live-71465034
https://jacobin.com/2025/01/germany-afd-cdu-far-right/
Merz is a far right populist and habitual liar. If he will not rule together with the pro Putin Nazis he will use it as a maximum threat for making a potential SPD coalition partner fall in line with him on all possible topics. If you follow more actively the next months, you will hear Merz lying day in day out.
-
Merz also said that he would never accept any working together with the AfD, not in public not in private. Anyone in the CDU that would do so, would be kicked out of the party immediately.
Now whjat we have seen instead on the past year is the CDU working together with the AfD often on the local and state level. on the federal level they finally worked together about three weeks back, when they first passed a resolution against Migration and then barely failed to pass a law together. Merz said, it isn't his fault if the AfD was voting together with them and if the other parties weren't willing to pass the [far right anti human rights anti constitutional rights] laws together with them.
https://www.dw.com/en/german-lawmakers-reject-contentious-immigration-law/live-71465034
https://jacobin.com/2025/01/germany-afd-cdu-far-right/
Merz is a far right populist and habitual liar. If he will not rule together with the pro Putin Nazis he will use it as a maximum threat for making a potential SPD coalition partner fall in line with him on all possible topics. If you follow more actively the next months, you will hear Merz lying day in day out.
Fair enough. I will probably read more about him within the near future. I'm not saying I absolutely believe he will stick to support for Ukraine and European independence, I'm just saying that I hope he does.
-
Merz' word is worthless. Give it time.
It's less than worthless. A dog turd on the sidewalk is worth more than the word of Friedrich Merz. That guy is a pathological opportunistic liar.
-
Merz has ruled out forming a government with AfD hasn't he? I think he did on TV last night. So I assume he will try to form a government with SPD.
Anyway, I really am not massively informed on German politics. But I've heard a couple of good things from Merz so far (his support for Ukraine, and his desire to make Europe more independent of the USA). I hope he will maintain his commitment to those ideas.
Merz has ruled out forming a government with AfD hasn’t he?
If Friedrich Merz rules out that it will rain later today, better bring an umbrella. That guy is a pathological liar and a shameless opportunist.
He will do whatever gives him the most power. The only reason for him to form a coalition with the SPD is that he can use the threat of the AfD to blackmail the (anyway spineless) SPD into doing whatever he wants.
-
CDU/CSU: 29%
AfD: 21%
where do your 2% come from?You are seriously summing up a coalition to get how much the afd was trashed (it wasn’t)? CDU was at 22 or so, afd at 20 or so, there was barely a 2% difference. The point isn’t that afd can’t rule now but that one German out of five voted for a neonazi party
-
You are seriously summing up a coalition to get how much the afd was trashed (it wasn’t)? CDU was at 22 or so, afd at 20 or so, there was barely a 2% difference. The point isn’t that afd can’t rule now but that one German out of five voted for a neonazi party
I honestly don't understand what you're trying to say.
CDU/CSU got 29% of the votes in this election.
AfD got 21%. -
We all know that but it should still be the main actor (NATO) the one who speaks, not its main member.
A single member thought should be just ignored legally speakingThe alternative to NATO is the EU, which is also a defensive alliance, does not include the US and has a lot of power outside of military matters. The only larger downside is that the UK is not a member, but other then that it is a much better tool.
-
I honestly don't understand what you're trying to say.
CDU/CSU got 29% of the votes in this election.
AfD got 21%.CDU alone got about 22% of the votes. CDU+CSU got 29%.
-
Merz has ruled out forming a government with AfD hasn’t he?
If Friedrich Merz rules out that it will rain later today, better bring an umbrella. That guy is a pathological liar and a shameless opportunist.
He will do whatever gives him the most power. The only reason for him to form a coalition with the SPD is that he can use the threat of the AfD to blackmail the (anyway spineless) SPD into doing whatever he wants.
Maybe I will end up disappointed then. I just hope to see Europe standing on its own two feet if the US has no interest in Europe anymore. And I hope to see Europe continuing to back Ukraine.
-
Maybe I will end up disappointed then. I just hope to see Europe standing on its own two feet if the US has no interest in Europe anymore. And I hope to see Europe continuing to back Ukraine.
I just hope to see Europe standing on its own two feet if the US has no interest in Europe anymore.
I doubt that Merz will do too much in this regard unless forced to, as he is in the pocket of his former employer, BlackRock, a US based investment firm.
-
This post did not contain any content.
If he means it, it is good. But it can't mean dependence from China or Russia.
-
CDU alone got about 22% of the votes. CDU+CSU got 29%.
Oh, you're one of those kinds of people.
-
I just hope to see Europe standing on its own two feet if the US has no interest in Europe anymore.
I doubt that Merz will do too much in this regard unless forced to, as he is in the pocket of his former employer, BlackRock, a US based investment firm.
Well, shit. I will just follow the news and hope for the best while expecting the worst.
-
CDU alone got about 22% of the votes. CDU+CSU got 29%.
For all intents and purposes, they are the same party. We're just (for utterly occult reasons) humouring Bavarians who want to feel special.
-
The alternative to NATO is the EU, which is also a defensive alliance, does not include the US and has a lot of power outside of military matters. The only larger downside is that the UK is not a member, but other then that it is a much better tool.
An alternative that both USA and RUS are now trying to fight with no success.
-
Then you don't know much about German politics.
I don't unfortunately. It's hard to break into the nuances without knowing German. I hope I'm wrong, but there's going to be more radicalization before your guys next election.
-
I don't know much about Merz but it's possible to have a politician who is shitty and self-serving, but who still says good things occasionally.
E.g. Boris Johnson. Purely a self-interested politician who has said many stupid things. But one of his views which I liked was his support for Ukraine.
Boris Johnson
Yes, that's probably a solid comparison. They are kinda similar. Just without the goofy behavior and even less charisma. And Merz is (thankfully) very strongly pro-EU.
