Plex is locking remote streaming behind a subscription in April
-
IIRC it has it. Not if you're behind VPN or a tunnel. Only over HTTPS.
Hmm i need to revisit it again. Thanks!
-
I run Jellyfin on Chromecast with Google TV every day, it works super well.
Unless you mean casting from your phone, then I don't know.
I will check it out!
-
Not in the way you’re probably thinking, no. The VPN (like Proton) will be isolating devices from each other. This is by design, so you don’t end up in situations like different customers seeing each other on the network.
Your router might be able to act as a VPN host. This would allow you to connect to your home network from anywhere, and use it just like you would use a service like Proton. And if your home network is set to allow devices to see each other, then you could see your Jellyfin server.
I see thank you.
But if I want to keep my Proton VPN connection active, I don't think what you're describing is doable.
That would mean being connected to two vpns at once wouldn't it?
-
The big thing for me with plex is user management. I am absolutely knowledgeable enough to set up jellyfin, but i dont want to deal with user management. Plex makes it easy, i tell them to make their own account and i just share my library. i dont have to reset passwords, they can do that themselves. However, it’s getting to the point where i will probably just switch to jellyfin and deal with it because of how bad plex is getting.
I'm only sharing access with a few friends and family, so I don't find it cumbersome. Usually I make their account using the Jellyfin app on my phone. I do sympathize with not wanting to do support, which is the main reason I don't even ask for help with the hosting costs. I don't want to feel any obligation.
-
IIRC it has it. Not if you're behind VPN or a tunnel. Only over HTTPS.
not if you’re behind VPN
Well that’s a very unexpected dealbreaker for me
-
If you mean that you are using Proton VPN on your Raspberry Pi to mask your downloading traffic, then no that same VPN will not help you access services like Jellyfin on your home network while you are remote.
Instead you'll want to use something like Tailscale (or Wireguard). You run it as a service on your home network and it then becomes your own VPN that you (or others) can use to connect to your home network when you are remote.
You could run Wireguard on the same RaspberryPi that you use for downloading but I would recommend against it assuming that you're running Proton VPN right on the host itself (and not inside a container).
Ahh I see, you helped me understand thz other comment. Thanks a lot!
-
I don't see anything in the linked article about a relay server
No, the article only mentions the feature by name, the docs for the feature mentions the relay https://support.plex.tv/articles/216766168-accessing-a-server-through-relay/
-
Not here to defend Plex' enshittification but you can still use Plex offline just fine. I had 0 issues yesterday when I had no internet all day.
I'll probably get the details wrong but my understanding is that when you sign in, you get an authorization token. That token is valid for some period of time, let's say 48 hours. You can use that cached token but let's say it's on your phone and not your TV. Maybe you haven't used Plex on the TV this week. Want to use your TV, out of luck. Want to use a different local account, out of luck. Want to use Plex longer than the token is good for, out of luck.
-
Why is this getting upvoted? Plex isn't running a server. You are. Your computer and your media files are quite literally "the server" that is serving the files to you remotely. Plex is at best doing authentication.
For remote streaming they do, here are their docs on it https://support.plex.tv/articles/216766168-accessing-a-server-through-relay/
-
Plex is trivial to set up, most plex users I know actually don’t use the arrs. Anyone can do it with a short list of instructions in minutes that mostly consist of “download app, make account, point to your media.”
I just setup jellyfin and it totally is the same. Install. Point it to a media folder. Setup port forwarding.
-
It’s not broken. It’s the core difference between Plex and something like Jellyfin. They handle all the infrastructure/security elements, you’re just hosting the media and transcoding. If you use Jellyfin and don’t know what you’re doing, you open the world up to your router.
I’m not saying everyone should use Plex, but it’s not broken in the way you’re describing. That’s how it works. It has to roll through their infrastructure at some point, it’s not designed for LAN playback.
I memba when it was primarily for LAN playback and you didn’t have to login to anything to use it on your LAN
-
Yes, it’s one thing to offer a lifetime subscription early on to get a large cash infusion and reward early adopters, but it’s a big red flag if they don’t get rid of the lifetime subscription eventually. What will happen is one by one, the people that use the service the most will switch to lifetime and your cash flow will dwindle. Eventually the only people left on the month to month are the casual users who don’t use it very often and will leave as soon as a price increase happens.
This is my exact concern.
If I pay for the lifetime pass now, what's to stop them from restricting even more features behind new types of subscriptions and paywalls. "We're adding back the 'Watch Together' feature but it requires a Platinum Plex subscription and will not be a part of Plex Lifetime Pass users."
Seems kind of inevitable honestly.
-
I memba when it was primarily for LAN playback and you didn’t have to login to anything to use it on your LAN
I don’t think plex has ever facilitated direct playback from your server to your screen. If that was the case at one point then it was many many years ago, but afaik that was never a feature.
-
I just setup jellyfin and it totally is the same. Install. Point it to a media folder. Setup port forwarding.
You don’t need to manually setup port forwarding with plex and if you want access off your network (such as when traveling) or to let others in it gets way more complicated.
-
I'll probably get the details wrong but my understanding is that when you sign in, you get an authorization token. That token is valid for some period of time, let's say 48 hours. You can use that cached token but let's say it's on your phone and not your TV. Maybe you haven't used Plex on the TV this week. Want to use your TV, out of luck. Want to use a different local account, out of luck. Want to use Plex longer than the token is good for, out of luck.
-
No, the article only mentions the feature by name, the docs for the feature mentions the relay https://support.plex.tv/articles/216766168-accessing-a-server-through-relay/
I see. So if you read that instruction you'll see it's the exact same setup that I outlined. They use a vpn to connect your client to your server and just negotiate the meeting in the middle. It's the exact same risk scenario as running a reverse proxy on your own vps. Unless I'm missing something else?
-
I used to use Plex, then one day my internet was down and since Plex couldn't phone home, it wouldn't let me log in to watch media ON MY LAN.
So yeah it's inherently broken. That's before you even consider the licensing.
i'm not sure why it would do this, i've never had any issues with watching plex while the internet is down (in fact that was one of my original uses for it, to have movies and tv in a building without internet). I don't have it turned on but I do know you can go into server settings -> network and set a list of IPs/subnets that can access without any authorization at all. That lets you use plex without even having a plex account afaik.
-
I memba when it was primarily for LAN playback and you didn’t have to login to anything to use it on your LAN
Plex still offers that option, it's just buried in the settings.
-
ITT: valid critiques of plex, understatements about how easy it is to set up and run Jellyfin for you and your friends/family, and a surprising number of people who don’t understand how plex works.
Ease of setup was how I just got one techie friend and two non-techie gamer friends to set up Plex servers and we had libraries shared to each other within 15-30 minutes. I don't want to think about explaining VPNs and SSL to them for the alternatives.
-
Because that basically requires transcoding for modern codecs. H265? Transcode. Subtitles? Transcode. The JF client on the same hardware can usually direct play.
Oh fair enough, I'd highly recommend enabling transcoding anyway it just eliminates all sorts of issues like this.
