Apple Pulls Encrypted iCloud Security Feature in UK Amid Government Backdoor Demands
-
This post did not contain any content.
Reminder that you don’t need to use iCloud backup; local backups still work fine and are encrypted.
-
No, but they’re part of 5 Eyes. The US government can ask MI5 to spy on US citizens, which gets around 4th amendment protections.
This will allow them to spy on any US citizens with dual citizenship.
Us citizen presumably still has access to encryption feature tho
-
A better title would be “Apple helps the US government bypass the 4th amendment”.
Yeah we don't have enough American news, we should start reframing other countries' news into how it affects America
-
but I thought apple were the good guys /s
I kind of think going no encryption is arguably better than agreeing to a backdoor, since it should make it clear to consumers that they can’t trust it as safe and should probably use an alternative that would be more secure. I don’t know how many trustworthy alternatives really exist on iOS, though, not least because Apple has allegedly used their position to discourage competitors to iCloud.
-
tbh if the government demanded fediverse servers do this then they'll probably comply as well, I really don't think this is apple's fault as much as i hate them and every similar tech megacorps
I don't think so
-
The UK is part of 5 Eyes. They swap info on citizens among members. No warrants, no constitutional protections. All they have to do is ask MI5 for info on Americans with dual citizenship.
That stretch of logic sounds an awful lot, like a post-hoc justification after assuming it was about the US. But ok
-
That stretch of logic sounds an awful lot, like a post-hoc justification after assuming it was about the US. But ok
No no no, he's just american and thinks the universe centers around the US
-
Reminder that you don’t need to use iCloud backup; local backups still work fine and are encrypted.
I don’t think it’s just the backups. Apple’s site says it’s things “such as” wallet, notes, photos, documents, bookmarks, reminders, voice memos, shortcuts, messages backup, and device backup. The such as seems to imply there’s more.
-
Us citizen presumably still has access to encryption feature tho
Not if they are in the UK? Idk, that’s probably a weird edge case, but unless we’re all free, nobody is.
-
Yeah we don't have enough American news, we should start reframing other countries' news into how it affects America
It affects certain people from America. I have a relative who is directly affected by this.
-
That stretch of logic sounds an awful lot, like a post-hoc justification after assuming it was about the US. But ok
One of my in-laws has dual England/US citizenship. They divide their time between the two countries. It directly effects them.
-
No no no, he's just american and thinks the universe centers around the US
No, the only thing I wish would center around the US is an asteroid. I absolutely hate it here, but I don’t have the means to leave.
-
One of my in-laws has dual England/US citizenship. They divide their time between the two countries. It directly effects them.
I don't doubt that. But its still a large stretch, to think the UK passed a law applying to all UK citizens, specifically to give the US access to a few thousand dual citizens.
I'm thinking LoudWaterHombre was right. You simply have an extremely US centric mindset.
-
I don't doubt that. But its still a large stretch, to think the UK passed a law applying to all UK citizens, specifically to give the US access to a few thousand dual citizens.
I'm thinking LoudWaterHombre was right. You simply have an extremely US centric mindset.
Apple is a US based company. For them to just roll over sets a bad precedent, especially for our fascists who are now running the show here.
What’s to stop the US government from going after the same services here? What’s about Tor or VPN services?
The authoritarians will smell blood in the water after this. Since the big player just gave up, who will stand in their way?
-
tbh if the government demanded fediverse servers do this then they'll probably comply as well, I really don't think this is apple's fault as much as i hate them and every similar tech megacorps
Bur what about servers that are not based in the UK? They are not officiallly doing business there, they just happen to be accessoble from there. And with Fediverse, you can specifically choose a server that suits your jurisdiction needs.
-
No, the only thing I wish would center around the US is an asteroid. I absolutely hate it here, but I don’t have the means to leave.
Hey Buddy, this article is about UK and you argue for it to be about the US. Clearly the UK did not pass a law to bend over for your orange overlord.
This whole discussion is bonkers.
-
This post did not contain any content.
Can governments stop micromanaging things they don’t understand? All they will achieve is inconvenience for people. Anybody who can potentially be targeted such as journalists, criminals, politicians know their attack vector. It’s not 90s when nobody knew shit about computers. Just encrypt on device and upload anywhere. No government will be able to decrypt as long as you are using robust algorithm.
-
Apple is a US based company. For them to just roll over sets a bad precedent, especially for our fascists who are now running the show here.
What’s to stop the US government from going after the same services here? What’s about Tor or VPN services?
The authoritarians will smell blood in the water after this. Since the big player just gave up, who will stand in their way?
Now you're moving the goal post, and pointing to a slippery slope, still trying to justify your original misunderstanding. It's alright to be wrong sometimes.
-
Bur what about servers that are not based in the UK? They are not officiallly doing business there, they just happen to be accessoble from there. And with Fediverse, you can specifically choose a server that suits your jurisdiction needs.
that just depends on how comfortable the instance owner is, if i was hosting I'd ip block the UK
-
that just depends on how comfortable the instance owner is, if i was hosting I'd ip block the UK
I am IP-blocked by a lot of things. At some point a large percentage of population just gets used to the fact that VPNs/proxies are now just a mandatory part of the internet usage.
