Lemmy be like
-
AI is bad and people who use it should feel bad.
So cancer cell detection is now bad and those doing it should feel bad?
The world isn't black'n white.
-
Like it or not, that is an actual example.
I can lay in my bed and turn off the lights without touching my phone, or turn on certain muisic without touching my phone.
I could ask if I remembered to lock the front door etc.
But okay, I'll play your game, let's pretend that doesn't count.
I can use my local AI to draft documents or emails speeding up the process a lot.
Or I can used it to translate.
If you want to live your life like that, go for that's your choice. But I don't think those applications are worth the cost of running an LLM. To be honest I find it frivolous.
I'm not against LLMs as a concept, but the way they get shoved into everything without thought and without an "AI" free option is absurd. There are good reasons why people have a knee-jerk anti-AI reaction, even if they can't articulate it themselves.
-
synthophobes are easily manipulated
You could have taken a screenshot from Spielberg's A.I. Artificial Intelligence.
It's funny how much that movie got right. I don't think it was meant to be predictive. Many Lemmy users will probably think it is the greatest comedy ever made.
-
If you want to live your life like that, go for that's your choice. But I don't think those applications are worth the cost of running an LLM. To be honest I find it frivolous.
I'm not against LLMs as a concept, but the way they get shoved into everything without thought and without an "AI" free option is absurd. There are good reasons why people have a knee-jerk anti-AI reaction, even if they can't articulate it themselves.
wrote last edited by [email protected]It's not expensive for me to run a local LLM, I just use the hardware I'm already using for gaming.
Electricity is cheap and most people with a gaming PC probably use more electricity gaming than they would running their own LLM and asking it some questions.I'm also against shoving AI in evening, and not making it Opt-In. I'm also worried about privacy and concentration of power etc.
But just outright saying LLMs are bad is rediculous.
And saying there is no good reason to use them is rediculous. Can we stop doing that.
-
I personally think of AI as a tool, what matters is how you use it. I like to think of it like a hammer. You could use a hammer to build a house, or you could smash someone's skull in with it. But no one's putting the hammer in jail.
wrote last edited by [email protected]I see the today AI situation more as giving to everyone an helicopter. It improves mobility a lot, but not enough people really understand how it works and how to use it well.
It can save lives, it can solve problems, but give it to everyone without teaching them how to use it well and you'll get chaos.
And this brings along the fact that it consumes a lot of power.
-
I think you are underestimating how adaptable humans are. We absolutely conform to the systems that govern us, and they are NOT equally likely to produce bad outcomes.
Every system eventually ends with someone corrupted with power and greed wanting more. Putin and his oligrachs, Trump and his oligarchs... Xi isn't great, but at least I haven't heard news about the Uyghurs situation for a couple of years now. Hope things are better there nowadays and people aren't going missing anymore just for speaking out against their government.
-
Wrong.
The problem are humans, the same things that happen under capitalism can (and would) happen under any other system because humans are the ones who make these things happen or allow them to happen.Problems would exist in any system, but not the same problems. Each system has its set of problems and challenges. Just look at history, problems change. Of course you can find analogies between problems, but their nature changes with our systems.
Hunger, child mortality, pollution, having no free time, war, censorship, mass surveilence,... these are not constant through history. They happen more or less depending on the social systems in place, which vary constantly. -
So is eating meat, flying, gaming, going om holiday, basically if you exist you should feel bad
How does one feel bar?
-
No hope commenting like this, just get ready getting downvoted with no reason. People use wrong terms and normalize it.
It's funny watching you AI bros climb over each other to be the first with a what about-ism.
-
So cancer cell detection is now bad and those doing it should feel bad?
The world isn't black'n white.
Don't be obtuse, you walnut. I'm obviously not equating medical technology with 12-fingered anime girls and plagiarism.
-
AI is bad and people who use it should feel bad.
You mean a subset of LLM that are trained on bad human behaviours
-
as an aussie, yeah, then you should stop people from having guns
i honestly wouldn’t be surprised if the total number of gun deaths in australia since we banned guns (1996) was less than the number of gun deaths in the US THIS WEEK
the reason is irrelevant: the cause is obvious… and id have bought the “to stop a tyrannical government” argument a few years ago, but ffs there’s all the kids dying in school and none of the stop the tyrant, so maybe that’s a fucking awful argument and we have it right down under
I’ve never understood how a redneck prepper thinks he’s going to protect himself with a bunch of guns from a government that has millions of soldiers, tanks, machine guns, sidewinder misses and nuclear weapons.
-
The algorithm is a bunch of math. It's not until someone wants to run it that it needs any energy.
No shit, chumly. How many times a second do you think that math is "run"?
-
This post did not contain any content.
Lots of AI is technologically interesting and has tons of potential, but this kind of chatbot and image/video generation stuff we got now is just dumb.
-
This post did not contain any content.wrote last edited by [email protected]
"B-But you don't understand, AI DESTROYS le epic self employed artists and their bottom line! Art is a sacred thing that we all do for fun and not for work, therefore AI that automates the process is EVIL!"
- Actual thought process of some people
-
But he isn't speaking the truth. AI itself is a massive strain on the environment, without any true benefit. You are being fed hype and lies by con men. Data centers being built to supply AIs are using water and electricity at alarming rates, taking away the resources from actual people living nearby, and raising the cost of those utilities at the same time.
https://www.realtor.com/advice/finance/ai-data-centers-homeowner-electric-bills-link/
The same can be said for taking flights to go on holiday.
Flying emits way exponentially more CO2 and supports the oil industry
-
Where are you seeing more than 200 upvotes on any post?
Literally this post lol
-
This post did not contain any content.
Why is the other arrow also pointing up?
-
"B-But you don't understand, AI DESTROYS le epic self employed artists and their bottom line! Art is a sacred thing that we all do for fun and not for work, therefore AI that automates the process is EVIL!"
- Actual thought process of some people
Um, have you tried practicing? Just draw a stick figure or hire an artist, this will easily solve all of your problems. You're welcome.
-
It's not expensive for me to run a local LLM, I just use the hardware I'm already using for gaming.
Electricity is cheap and most people with a gaming PC probably use more electricity gaming than they would running their own LLM and asking it some questions.I'm also against shoving AI in evening, and not making it Opt-In. I'm also worried about privacy and concentration of power etc.
But just outright saying LLMs are bad is rediculous.
And saying there is no good reason to use them is rediculous. Can we stop doing that.
It's not expensive for me to run a local LLM, I just use the hardware I'm already using for gaming. Electricity is cheap and most people with a gaming PC probably use more electricity gaming than they would running their own LLM and asking it some questions.
I don't personally know the monetary cost of running one of these things locally, and I should be more informed before I make sweeping statements.
I'm also against shoving AI in evening, and not making it Opt-In. I'm also worried about privacy and concentration of power etc.
Then we are on the same page
But just outright saying LLMs are bad is rediculous.
I didn't say that, in fact I said that I didn't have a problem with them as a concept, go back to the previous point for a reason why someone might have instant dislike of "AI"
And saying there is no good reason to use them is rediculous. Can we stop doing that.
I also didn't say that. I just said your examples weren't good uses of it. I happen to think that there are very good applications for this technology, but none of those are publicly available GenAI slop and soulless automation systems/assistants that are really just corporate spyware to collect advertising data.
If you want a "smart home" with voice commands because it make you feel like Tony Stark talking to Jarvis go right ahead, but don't pretend that your locally run LLM is what people are talking about when they level criticism against "AI" (or even if they just say 'AI bad')
