What happens if you have more than 1 free accounts on privacy-respecting email providers such as Protonmail or Tutanota?
-
Their ToS only allow one account per person...
Does anyone here have more than 1 free account on such platforms?
Has there been cases where people got banned for having more than 1 free account?
-
Due to CGNAT it's likely to have up to hundreds or thousands of unrelated customers sharing an IPv4 address
Perhaps, but if I connect from my IP and then 30sec later to a different account on the same IP, and that happens routinely for the same accounts, one could reasonably assume it was potentially one person using two accounts.
You could circumvent that with a VPN, since those IP ranges are usually known and known to be shared, but probably not with a residential IP address.
Anyway, it's just a guess. I don't know with any certainty how they might sus out somebody breaking the policy. I just believe that if they find people doing that with regularity, the free tier many people enjoy can be revoked, and so it would be a dick move to try to abuse account creation.
-
Their ToS only allow one account per person...
Does anyone here have more than 1 free account on such platforms?
Has there been cases where people got banned for having more than 1 free account?
I researched this a bit previously for proton and I think there was one case where someone had their account deleted but they were using the service excessively. I also read that if you do upgrade to a premium subscription support can help you merge your accounts together so I guess they kind of support it. If your making a few accounts even on the same IP you are probably fine just don't login to them in quick succession and you will probably be fine. I do suggest you use an aliasing service when you can.
-
Perhaps, but if I connect from my IP and then 30sec later to a different account on the same IP, and that happens routinely for the same accounts, one could reasonably assume it was potentially one person using two accounts.
You could circumvent that with a VPN, since those IP ranges are usually known and known to be shared, but probably not with a residential IP address.
Anyway, it's just a guess. I don't know with any certainty how they might sus out somebody breaking the policy. I just believe that if they find people doing that with regularity, the free tier many people enjoy can be revoked, and so it would be a dick move to try to abuse account creation.
Sure, but on my WiFi network with my flat mates there would be like five concurrently logged in email accounts constantly connected and receiving traffic from proton. And then behind CGNAT that might extend to a hundred people concurrently logged in with one IP.
The false positives would drive away so many more paying or future paying customers it wouldn't be worth trying
Only thing I can think of is fingerprinting devices but then that'd be obvious, break their business model and also drive away customers
-
Their ToS only allow one account per person...
Does anyone here have more than 1 free account on such platforms?
Has there been cases where people got banned for having more than 1 free account?
Yeah, I remember someone getting all their Proton accounts banned, but they had a large amount, basically using it as a disposable provider. Don't be that person and ruin it for everyone.
I have two with Proton and have had two with Tuta. I don't think either would bother coming down on that. It could very easily be two people sharing a device with different email accounts or so forth.
-
Probably nothing would happen to you. They might correlate your IP address and ban you, but that's likely it.
However, don't do that. Servers aren't free, and if people abuse the charity of these services, they'll stop offering free options for everyone.
If you need extra addresses, use something like https://addy.io/. if you need more storage, might be worth considering self-hosting your email.
Sure but they probably make more than enough money. Email is really cheap to run
-
If not want multiple emails, why have “switch account” button? (Proton)
Because if you pay, you can have as many Proton accounts as you please.
-
Their ToS only allow one account per person...
Does anyone here have more than 1 free account on such platforms?
Has there been cases where people got banned for having more than 1 free account?
Proton is CIA
-
Probably nothing would happen to you. They might correlate your IP address and ban you, but that's likely it.
However, don't do that. Servers aren't free, and if people abuse the charity of these services, they'll stop offering free options for everyone.
If you need extra addresses, use something like https://addy.io/. if you need more storage, might be worth considering self-hosting your email.
Addy is nice but sometimes blocked, and a bit expensive.
-
Addy is nice but sometimes blocked, and a bit expensive.
Free for me. I haven't paid them a cent. Depends what you need out of the service.
-
Sure but they probably make more than enough money. Email is really cheap to run
Perhaps, but you're just guessing. I don't know their operating costs, and I would suspect that neither do you.
If you know better, please enlighten me.
-
Proton explicitly enabled keeping 2 free accounts on the mobile apps quite some time ago, probably more than a year, so they're cool with you having 2 like that.
If you get more, you'll be hampered at the application level, but, unless it's like a load of accounts for spam purposes, having just a handful shouldn't get you banned, I believe
How do you do that i don’t see an option
-
How do you do that i don’t see an option
Open the sidebar, tap the top right three dot menu, tap Add Account
-
Proton is CIA
idk if i would inherently say that, but the CEO does have some worms in his brain so there's that.
-
Free for me. I haven't paid them a cent. Depends what you need out of the service.
For sure, but the lack of feature to reply/send is certainly limiting after a certain point
-
Their ToS only allow one account per person...
Does anyone here have more than 1 free account on such platforms?
Has there been cases where people got banned for having more than 1 free account?
Nothing yet. This came about before I learned to use email aliases, so I created a couple accounts in fear of being correlated across shopping sites and other services. Though at no point did I consume more than 500 MB across my accounts, the limit for one free account.
If anyone at Proton is reading this, my apologies and many thanks for graciously providing these accounts for free the past several years. I'll stop leeching resources once I finish migrating to my new email provider.
-
For sure, but the lack of feature to reply/send is certainly limiting after a certain point
I'm able to reply just fine. They have a special address that goes to your inbox, and when you reply, it looks like you're replying from that alias and not your main email address.
That was one of the first things I checked on, since replying is sometimes necessary.
You can also send by going into your Aliases and clicking "Send" by one of your aliases. This will open a dialogue that creates the recipient address you need to use in whatever email address is verified with Addy.
-
Danged zombies ruining it for the rest of us.
I cloned myself so he could live my dream of multiple accounts.
-
I'm able to reply just fine. They have a special address that goes to your inbox, and when you reply, it looks like you're replying from that alias and not your main email address.
That was one of the first things I checked on, since replying is sometimes necessary.
You can also send by going into your Aliases and clicking "Send" by one of your aliases. This will open a dialogue that creates the recipient address you need to use in whatever email address is verified with Addy.
Free plan states
Anonymous Reply + Send From Daily Limit "X"
as unsupported for the free plan... So I'm quite surprised
-
Perhaps, but you're just guessing. I don't know their operating costs, and I would suspect that neither do you.
If you know better, please enlighten me.
Again, just relatively common sense.
Postfix etc... isn't that hard to run. I selfhost a mailcow installation, which is considered "full" and "expensive to run" and it's still really fine to run. Not expensive when scaling up to multiple users, the most important is the initial performance cost per instance.
We're mostly paying for salaries and R&D I believe. They're developing other services and stuff, but they could easily charge less and still be profitable, they just wouldn't have this much reserves.
Perhaps they don't realise that by lowering their subscription costs, they could get more users... like me
