Apple Caved
-
BBC News - Apple pulls data protection tool after UK government security row BBC
"In a statement Apple said it was "gravely disappointed" that the security feature would no longer be available to British customers."
-
P [email protected] shared this topic
-
This isn’t caving, is it? This is not making a backdoor.
Arguably it is making a front door / cutting one’s nose to spite the face, but I don’t think it’s caving.
-
A better title would be “Apple helps the US government bypass the 4th amendment”.
-
WE ARE FUCKED
-
I know Apple is an American company but what does this have to do with the US?
-
The UK government's obsession with being a Big Brother is so damn frustrating. A preview of what other governments will try and become in the near future, unfortunately.
-
Apple has three realistic options:
- Submit to the UK's demands and grant them a backdoor to encrypted backups.
- Disable encrypted backups in the UK.
- Leave the UK market entirely.
They went with #2, which is probably the least user-hostile option available.
From 1500GMT on Friday, any Apple user in the UK attempting to turn it on has been met with an error message.
Existing users' access will be disabled at a later date.
I am very interested in seeing what the UX around this will be. Ideally, they should give users direct notice well in advance, so they have time to plan a migration or mitigation. Of course, Apple makes it basically impossible to perform a full backup through any mechanism except iCloud, so......one more example of how vendor lock-in is inherently a security and privacy risk.
-
That’s not caving. That’s standing up and saying fuck you, your people don’t matter as much as the rest of the world because you’re lunatics.
-
Apple Caved. I'm no apple fan but what exactly would not caving have been here?
Make the backdoor?
Pull out of the UK ?
Fund an expensive legal battle against the laws of a democratically elected government? -
Curious what happens if you were someone would had opted in to ADP. If your data is fully encrypted, do you just get to keep using it that way? Does this only impact new users? Or, is Apple going to somehow capture users encryption keys and revert ADP?
-
The BBC article clarifies (not sure if NYT does as well, I can't read it)
Users will have a grace period to opt out of encryption before their data is deleted. Apple states they do not have the ability to automatically unencrypt the data.
-
I've got an android
-
I also have an Android and iPhone. It seems like I’ll have to switch from iCloud to self-hosting.
-
Apple did not cave
End to end encryption is MEANINGLESS if someone else also has a key
They removed a feature in the region to avoid setting a precedent that they would backdoor their feature on the whims of a shitty government
Now Apple gets to tell the UK that they would love to give fully encrypted backups but the UK government does not like encryption and security
-
America can't legally spy on its own people
The UK can
And the UK is in an intelligence cooperation with America
-
yeah I admit 'apple caved' was kinda just a gut reaction 'apple bad - encrypted backup good'.
If they fully caved we likely wouldn't have known about it, they'd have just put in a backdoor and given themselves and/or the uk encryption keys.
Denying encrypted backups because of this is probably best.You could argue apple does have the resources for a a legal battle, but you also can't really expect them to do that. They're not liberty or big brother watch.
I doubt that would go well in domestic courts anyway. After that, the ECHR could be sympathetic on proportionallity & art.8 grounds but its a lot of effort.maybe I should edit the title?
-
yea, its a blow to uk user's privacy & security but not caving. Caving would be implimenting a backdoor.
Title was a bit of an annoyed initial reaction, sorry there...
maybe best to improve it, i'm not sure? -
I would leave the title. It's important that people be critical but willing to adjust opinion.
Apple has fought these in the past (San Bernardino shooting / Phone unlock). It is honestly best for them to never take a case on this issue that they could lose.
-
Here in the UK, many typical phone users already assume that their data is shared anyway. Every person that i spoke to about this today asked why I think it's a problem as they have nothing to hide. A worrying position.
-
Exactly why we must shift from privacy to control, power.
