Why I am not impressed by A.I.
-
It doesn't even see the word 'strawberry', it's been tokenized in a way to no longer see the 'text' that was input.
It's more like it sees a question like:
How many 'r's in 草莓?And it spits out an answer not based on analysis of the input, but a model of what people might have said.
-
-
Yes, at some point the meme becomes the training data and the LLM doesn't need to answer because it sees the answer all over the damn place.
-
-
I really don't see the point OP is trying to make with this example though. It accurately answered their misspelled question, and also accurately answered the question they were apparently trying to ask. I don't see the problem.
-
Except many many experts have said this is not why it happens. It cannot count letters in the incoming words. It doesn't even know what "words" are. It has abstracted tokens by the time it's being run through the model.
It's more like you don't know the word strawberry, and instead you see:
How many 'r's in
?And you respond with nonsense, because the relation between 'r' and
is nonsensical. -
It doesn't see "strawberry" or "straw" or "berry". It's closer to think of it as seeing
, an abstract token representing the same concept that the training data associated with the word. -
What gaps in functionality do you see being demonstrated in this example? It answered both the literal question and the intended question, recognizing the misspelling. I may be having a complete brain-fart but to me this seems like a demo of it working very well.
-
-
How many strawberries could a strawberry bury if a strawberry could bury strawberries
-
OHHHHHHH.... my bad. I'm an idiot. Being an LLM it's giving the answer it thinks a human such as myself would come up with.
-
Works fine for me in o3-mini-high:
Counting letters in “strawberry”
Alright, I’m checking: the word “strawberry” is spelled S T R A W B E R R Y. Let me count the letters: S (1), T (2), R (3), A (4), W (5), B (6), E (7), R (8), R (9), Y (10). There are three R’s: in positions 3, 8, and 9. So, the answer is 3. Even if we ignore case, the count still holds. Therefore, there are 3 r’s in “strawberry.”
-
Maybe you're a bot too...
-
Not last time I checked, but we all could be as far as you know.
-
Or you might eliminate some that are what you are looking for because the summaries are inaccurate.
Guess it depends on whether an unreliable system is still better than being overwhelmed with choices.
-
You asked a stupid question and got a stupid response, seems fine to me.
-
Yes, nobody asking that question is wonderring about the "straw" part of the word. They're asking, is the "berry" part one, or two "r"s
-
A normal person would say 'strawberry with two "r"s'
-
Answer, you're using it wrong /stevejobs
-
Really? AI has been marketed as being able to count the r’s in “strawberry?” Please link to this ad.
